Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Peril from the Provinces

The post Which leaders make history? at Marginal Revolution quotes the book Arsenals of Folly:

Leaders who make history are often provincials: Provincials attempt what sophisticates consider naive.

(Richard Rhodes: Arsenals of Folly: the Making of the Nuclear Arms Race.)

I was reminded of:

Judge, Sir, of my surprise, when I found that a very great proportion of the assembly (a majority, I believe, of the members who attended) was composed of practitioners in the law. It was composed, not of distinguished magistrates, who had given pledges to their country of their science, prudence, and integrity; not of leading advocates, the glory of the bar; not of renowned professors in universities;—but for the far greater part, as it must in such a number, of the inferior, unlearned, mechanical, merely instrumental members of the profession. There were distinguished exceptions; but the general composition was of obscure provincial advocates, of stewards of petty local jurisdictions, country attornies, notaries, and the whole train of the ministers of municipal litigation, the fomenters and conductors of the petty war of village vexation. From the moment I read the list, I saw distinctly, and very nearly as it has happened, all that was to follow.

(Edmund Burke: Reflections on the French Revolution.)

Wasn't Robespierre from the provinces, too?

No comments: