Friday, November 17, 2006

Mutilation as transhumanism

There are many science fiction stories about groups of people who voluntarily renounce some limb, organ, or mental faculty in order to achieve a state they consider more desirable than plain vanilla human. The novels of Greg Egan feature voluntary asexuals and autists. In Samuel R. Delany's Aye, and Gomorrah, astronauts are neutered to avoid the efects of space radiation on gametes. Parts of Michel Houllebeq's The Possibility of an Island take place in a future "utopia" where sexuality has been abolished (see also: Postgenderism).

In Bernard Wolfe's Limbo, amputations of limbs are a mark of status, the more the better. The zoanthropes in Gene Wolfe's Book of the New Sun renounce their higher mental faculties to live a life of savagery. The scanners in Cordwainer Smith's story Scanners live in vain are humans whose sensory nerves are cut to allow them to undergo the rigors of space travel. They come to regard their status as noble and desirable, an resent an invention that makes their transformation obsolete. The cyborgs in David R. Bunch's Moderan constantly attempt to reduce their organic parts to the bare minimum.

One man's mutilation is another's enhancement. All of the above transformations could be considered varieties of transhumanism. At least, by the characters who wanted them.

Given that, in the simpler cases, the technology required is just a well sharpened knife, there are historical precedents to those fictional movements. The millenarian russian sect from the nineteenth century called the Skoptzy, for example:

As their title indicates, the main feature of the sect was sexual mutilation. This they called their "baptism of fire." Of this there were two kinds, the "lesser" and "greater seal" (i.e. partial and complete mutilation). In this the Skoptsi maintained that they were fulfilling Christ's counsel of perfection in Matthew xix. 12 and xviii. 8, 9. A terrible operation with similar purpose was sometimes performed on the women. The earliest records of such female genital mutilations date from 1815. Usually the breasts only were amputated, according to the 1911 encyclopedia. Other accounts suggest that the labia were also removed.

(Wikipedia entry for Skoptzy)

The most surprising fact about them is the kind of people who joined:

Nobles, military and naval officers, civil servants, priests and merchants were to be found in its ranks, and so rapidly did the numbers increase that 515 men and 240 women were transported to Siberia between 1847 and 1866 without seriously threatening its existence. In, 187? many trials of Skoptsi took place all over Russia. In 1874 the sect numbered at least 5444, including 1465 women. Of these 703 men and 100 women had mutilated themselves.

(ibid.)

More recently, many members of the Heaven's Gate cult also castrated themselves (science fiction, along with Christianity and New Age stuff, was an important part of their belief system). And then there is the lesbian couple who wanted their child to be deaf like them.

I suspect that, in time, mutilative practices will become central to transhumanism, either by religious reasons, group identity ones, or just plain ol' crazyness.

No comments: